Last updated: November 2026
There is a particular sinking feeling when a mechanic says the words “engine” and “rebuild” in the same sentence. A blown engine or a failed automatic gearbox is one of the most expensive things that can happen to a car, and it often happens to cars that are otherwise fine. If you are stuck with a car with a blown engine, it is worth stepping back before you approve a big quote and looking at all your options, including selling the car as it is.
Signs Something Serious Has Happened
Only a qualified mechanic can confirm a major failure, but these signs often point to one:
- Heavy white or blue smoke from the exhaust that does not clear
- A loud knocking or rattling from the engine
- Oil that looks milky, or coolant disappearing with no visible leak
- The engine overheating repeatedly
- The gearbox slipping, refusing to engage or changing harshly
- A car that will not move at all even though the engine runs
If you notice any of these, stop driving the car. Running a damaged engine can turn a repairable problem into a write off. If it is a warning light rather than a clear failure, start with our guide to selling a car with a warning light on.
Your Three Real Options
| Option | Upside | Downside |
|---|---|---|
| Repair or rebuild the original engine or gearbox | Keeps the car and its known history | Often the most expensive choice, and other faults can appear once it is opened up |
| Fit a second hand or reconditioned unit | Usually cheaper than a full rebuild | Quality varies, and warranty terms differ widely |
| Sell the car as it is | No repair bill, money in hand, problem solved | You receive less than the car would be worth in perfect working order |
The Question That Decides It
Ask yourself one thing: will the car be worth more after the repair than the repair costs, by enough to make it worthwhile? To answer it, you need three numbers:
- The repair quote, in writing, including labour
- What the car would be worth with the fault fixed
- What the car is worth now, as it is, with the fault
If the repair cost is close to the gap between the second and third numbers, the repair does not really pay for itself. That is common with older, high kilometre cars, where a major engine or gearbox repair can approach the value of the whole car.
Hidden Costs People Forget
- Towing to and from the workshop
- Time without a car, which can stretch to weeks if parts are hard to find
- Related repairs found once the engine is out, such as mounts, hoses, the radiator or the clutch
- A roadworthy certificate, if you plan to sell privately after the repair
Our article on the roadworthy trap explains how a “simple” fix can grow once a car is pulled apart.
When Repairing Is Worth It
Repairing usually makes sense when the car is fairly new, has low kilometres, is otherwise in excellent condition, and you plan to keep driving it for years. It can also make sense for models that hold their value well or that are hard to replace. In those cases, get two written quotes and ask what warranty comes with the work.
When Selling As Is Is the Better Call
Selling usually wins when the car is older, has high kilometres, or has other wear that will need attention soon. It also makes sense when you need a car straight away and do not want to wait weeks for a repair, or when you would rather put the repair money towards a replacement.
Our guide on what is worth fixing before you sell covers smaller repairs too.
Who Buys a Car With a Blown Engine?
Private buyers mostly do not. They want a car they can drive home, and a registered car sold privately needs a roadworthy. Licensed car buyers, wreckers and recyclers do buy cars with major mechanical failures, because they can repair them, reuse parts or recycle them properly. We explain the difference in junk vs salvage cars.
Common Myths About Cars With Major Faults
- “It is worthless now.” Not usually. The body, interior, wheels, electronics and other parts still have value, and a buyer who can repair or reuse them will pay for that.
- “I need to fix it before anyone will buy it.” Private buyers may expect that, but licensed buyers purchase non running cars as they are every day.
- “I will have to pay to get it towed away.” A reputable buyer includes collection in the price. We never charge a pickup fee.
- “A second hand engine is always the cheap fix.” Sometimes it is. But labour, the condition of the replacement and any warranty all matter, so compare it properly against selling.
How to Get a Fair Price for a Car That Does Not Run
- Share the mechanic’s diagnosis. A written report helps a buyer price the car accurately.
- Be clear about what works. Body condition, interior, tyres and electrics still count.
- Keep the parts together. If the car was partly pulled apart, keep everything with it.
- Do not pay for further diagnosis if you have already decided to sell.
Selling to Us
We buy cars with blown engines, failed gearboxes and other major faults across Melbourne and regional Victoria. Send photos and any repair quote or diagnosis, and you get a price straight away. That price holds unless a major fault turns up that was not mentioned. We collect the car from wherever it is, including a workshop, on a tow truck with no pickup fee, and pay on the spot.
See how we handle these cars on our sell a damaged car page, or get a figure through our cash for cars service before you approve that repair.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sell a car with a blown engine?
Yes. Licensed car buyers, wreckers and recyclers buy cars with major engine or gearbox failures as they are.
Is it worth fixing a blown engine?
It depends on the car. Compare the repair quote with how much more the car would be worth once fixed. On older, high kilometre cars, the repair often costs close to the car’s value.
Should I keep driving a car with engine problems?
No. Driving a car with a serious engine fault can cause more damage. Have it towed instead.
Do you buy cars with failed gearboxes?
Yes. We buy cars with gearbox, engine and electrical failures in any condition.
Can you collect a car from a workshop?
Yes. We can collect from a workshop, your home or wherever the car is, with no pickup fee.
Sources
Related Guides
About the author: Written by Steve, owner of Victorian Car Buyers, a licensed motor car trader (LMCT 12395) based in Delahey, Melbourne.
